Care to share the link?I just read a article on using vinegar to reduce nitrates, what is every ones opinion on this please?
400lt tank how much would you dose and is there any special type of vinegar to useI prefer Vinegar over the other alternatives for the following reasons:
- It is cheap and readily available.
- It is very diluted, thus very forgiving in case of over doses.
- Acetic Acid seems to promote sponges growth more than other carbons sources.
- I like to know exactly what I am dosing (in comparison to bio pellets, NoPOx, zeovit and other proprietary recipes)
Also, the current Vinegar dosing tables you will find on Randy's articles weren't written by him. They were actually added at a later stage by the editors, based on a simple conversion from the Vodka dosing table. That table sits on the safe side, which makes it very safe if followed correctly.
However, it also slows down the results and might not be enough to handle nitrates on heavily populated tanks.
In practice, many people on the forums have ramped up the Vinegar dosage much faster than what is recommended by the table, without seeing side effects. Furthermore, reports of dosage schemes much higher than recommended, aren't uncommon.
Basically it means: Start on the safe side, following the table and if it doesn't bring your nitrates to very low levels, go ahead and try dosing more than what is suggested at small increments.
Having that said, I would suggest to also get a better test kit. API is fine to tell if it is "nearly good, almost bad or really bad", but won't give you the precision needed to measure the very low levels of a carbon boosted tank.
2 x tangs, 2 x clown, 2 dragnets, 1 x wrasse, 1 blenny, 1 angle, 3 chromis, I feed 1 x day 3 x brine shrimp cubes, 1/2 lobster egg, next day pellets, heaps of marine pure in sump and lots of live rock in tank, shimmer is Aqua Medic blue 1000If you are already dosing nopox and this is not helping id think you might need to look at what is causing these massive nitrates and why no pox isnt helping.
have you got some more details about your system (hardware, stocking, feeding etc)?
10 ml a day, shimmer is good, clean it very second day, been using NoPOX for months, I dose in sump every morning, I was thinking of using vinegar in stead of NopOXSusan, I missed the bit that you are already dosing NoPox.
While there are virtual advantages of dosing multiple carbon sources (check VSV method), I wouldn't recommend mixing it up. It adds an extra variable to the equation and makes it harder to predict.
For sake of information completion, it is worth noting that NoPOX is much more concentrated than Vinegar, so don't try to apply Vinegar dosing tables to NoPOx.
How many ml/day are you currently dosing?
Is your skimmer skimmating more than before you started NoPOx?
When have you started dosing?
How and where do you dose?
Is that good for the fish, I feed the frozen socked in garlic only because I thought it was healthier of them, will is help with the nitrates , I defrost in ro water first@Susan Bates
Ever considered feeding pellet food exclusively and ditching frozen brine?
I like to think of it this way, brine shrimp and garlic are not found in the ocean.Is that good for the fish, I feed the frozen socked in garlic only because I thought it was healthier of them, will is help with the nitrates , I defrost in ro water first
You definitely don't want to mess around with carbon dosing while relying on an API test kit. I've known them to be up to 30ppm out compared to an electronic lab grade tester.:eekWhat do you think?I struggle all the time with nitrates can not keep them below 20 API test kit, everything else is good, I use NOPOX have cut back feeding do 20% water change a week, nothing works